Critical Inquiry

Winter 1995

Volume 21, Number 2

Excerpt from "Kafka 007" by O.K. Werckmeister:

"Although the work of Franz Kafka has never yielded an emblematic text or image of use for the culture of the Left, it has been drawn into the same field of ideological conflict because of its strong impact on the popular imagination. The word Kafkaesque has entered the everyday language of capitalist society, denoting an all-pervasive, menacing incommensurability between the experience and the reality of social relations so fundamental that the question of its political significance has imposed itself on many Kafka readers since the Second World War. Accordingly, a substantial part of the critical reception and interpretation of Kafka's work, insofar as it pertains to social relations, has also been conditioned by the cold war. This much became apparent when one of its cinematic adaptations, produced in 1990 in Prague, Kafka's hometown and the capital of a just-collapsed communist government, a film by American director Stephen Soderbergh entitled Kafka....

The conflict of anarchism and literature played out in Kafka facilitates the inconclusive ending of the film, since by definition anarchism is not obliged to provide political alternatives to the power it opposes. The conflict is abstract enough to keep the story line detached from the historical situation in the city of Prague at the time the film was made, the collapse of an oppressive government with the leading participation of a writer [Vaclav Havel]. Communism rather than anarchism would have been the touchstone for evaluating the political significance of the seeming submission to authority in Kafka's work, an issue that has preoccupied literary critics for a long time. Soderbergh, however, has narrowed "Kafka's" case down to the moral question of how one should behave toward an atrocious superior force that is beyond understanding and hence impervious to counteraction. He has placed the writer in the milieu of the Boheme, where since the nineteenth century literature and anarchism have traditionally met. At a bar table the conspirators call "Kafka" to account...."


Return to Table of Contents